CAVEAT: This list is by no means claimed to be complete. If you have any documented additions for me (professional, major junior, or collegiate only, please), send them my way, and you'll have both my undying appreciation and a mention in the "Thank You" page. What more could you want out of life?
Thanks to Alan Caldwell, Jason Bau, Mark Obermayer, Jocke Persson, and statistics (from HFBoards) for additions to the list!
NAME LEAGUE/TEAM DATE Michel Plasse Kansas City Blues, CHL February 21, 1971 Bill Smith New York Islanders, NHL November 28, 1979 Chris Clifford Kingston Canadiens, OHL January 7, 1987 Darcy Wakaluk Rochester Americans, AHL December 6, 1987 Ron Hextall Philadelphia Flyers, NHL December 8, 1987 Damian Rhodes Michigan Tech Huskies, WCHA January 21, 1989 Ron Hextall Philadelphia Flyers, NHL April 11, 1989 (SHG) (postseason) Olaf Kolzig Tri-City Americans, WHL November 29, 1989 Chris Osgood Medicine Hat Tigers, WHL January 3, 1991 Mike Torchia Canadian National Team 1991 Paul Cohen Springfield, AHL March 28, 1992 Jeff Calvert Tacoma Rockets, WHL December 29, 1992 Fred Brathwaite Detroit Junior Red Wings, AHL April 20, 1993 (postseason) Carl Picconatto Flint, UHL December 26, 1993 Jason Clague Red Deer Rebels, WHL March 28, 1994 (postseason) Cowin Saurdiff Hampton Roads, ECHL 1994-95 Robb Stauber Rochester Americans, AHL October 9, 1995 Chris Osgood Detroit Red Wings, NHL March 6, 1996 Nick Vitucci Charlotte Checkers, ECHL 1995-96 Olie Sundstrom Erie, ECHL 1995-96 Sean Gauthier South Carolina Stingrays, ECHL 1995-96 Fred Brathwaite Manitoba Moose, IHL November 9, 1996 Martin Brodeur New Jersey Devils, NHL April 17, 1997 (postseason) Andrew Allen University of Vermont, ECAC January 3, 1998 Chad Alban Michigan State Spartans, CCHA February 28, 1998 Damian Rhodes Ottawa Senators, NHL January 2, 1999 Dieter Kochan B.C. Icemen, UHL January 5, 1999 Jarmo Myllys Luleå Elitserien, SEL March 16, 1999 Mike Torchia Mohawk Valley Prowlers, UHL October 22, 1999 Christian Bronsard Syracuse Crunch, AHL October 30, 1999 J.F. Labbe Hartford WolfPack, AHL February 5, 2000 Martin Brodeur New Jersey Devils, NHL February 15, 2000 (GWG) Jose Theodore Montreal Canadiens, NHL January 2, 2001 Mark Bernard Toledo Storm, ECHL March 27, 2001 Chris Mason Milwaukee Admirals, AHL October 15, 2001 Evgeni Nabokov San Jose Sharks, NHL March 10, 2002 Mike Smith Lexington Men O'War, ECHL October 26, 2002 Brian Eklund Pensacola Ice Pilots, ECHL December 5, 2003 Mika Noronen Buffalo Sabres, NHL February 14, 2004 Justin Peters St. Michael's Majors, OHL March 30, 2004 (postseason) Antero Niittymaki Philadelphia Phantoms, AHL April 11, 2004 (GWG/SHG/OTG) Michel Robinson Rockford IceHogs, UHL December 29, 2004 Trevor Koenig Atlantic City Brdwlk Bullies, ECHL March 3, 2005 Seamus Kotyk Milwaukee Admirals, AHL April 17, 2005 Antoine Lafleur Prince Edward Island Rocket, QMJHL September 25, 2005 (QMJHL debut) Chris Mason Nashville Predators, NHL April 15, 2006 Mike Wall Arizona Sundogs, CHL March 17, 2007 Drew MacIntyre Manitoba Moose, AHL February 20, 2008 (GWG/OTG) Peter Delmas Lewiston Maineiacs, QMJHL December 6, 2008 Maxime Gougeon Rimouski Oceanic, QMJHL December 6, 2008